Location

By Location Alaska Albuquerque Allentown Amsterdam Anaheim Anchorage Ann Arbor Atlanta Austin Baton Rouge Bend Binghamton Boston Boulder Canada Cardiff Charlotte Chatsworth Chicago Chippenham Cleveland Columbia SC Columbus Dallas Denver Des Moines Detroit Edmonton Eugene Fayetteville Fort McMurray Fredericton Gainesville Glendale Great Falls Greensboro Harbor City Harrisburg Hawaii Hawthorne Hollywood Honolulu houston Ithaca Kalkaska Kelowna Koreatown Las Vegas Lima London London (Canada) Los Angeles Louisville Manchester Miami Minneapolis/St Paul Montreal Nashville New Orleans New York City Nickelsville Norway Oakland Ocala Oslo Ottawa Oxford Paradise Pasadena Peru Philadelphia Phoenix Pine Ridge Pittsburgh Portland Reseda Sacramento Salt Lake City San Diego San Francisco San Jose San Luis Obispo Santa Monica Saskatoon Seattle Shawnee Skid Row Springfield St John's St Louis St. Petersburg Syracuse Tacoma Tampa Toronto Traverse City Tulsa United Kingdom Vancouver Venice Beach Vermont Victoria Wales Washington DC Wentzville Westwood Wichita Wilmington Winnipeg Yellowknife By topic Addiction Advocacy Affordable housing Art and Music Awareness Charity Cold Weather College Students Community Involvement Coronavirus Couch Surfing Couple Criminalization Data Disabled Divorce Domestic violence Drug testing Education Employment Eviction Ex-convict Faith based Families Family conflict Female Financial crisis Foster care Harm reduction Health care HIV/AIDS Homeless count Homeless deaths Hostels (UK shelters) Hotels Housing First HUD Human trafficking Identification Incarceration Indigenous Invisible People Invisible Stories Job loss K2/Spice (Synthetic Marijuana) LGBT Libraries Lived Experience Male Mental illness Mobile Homeless Natural disasters NIMBY Outreach Panhandling Peer Support Pets Poverty Pregnant PTSD Public Feeding Racism Recycling Relationships Research Rural Schools Seniors Sex Offenders Sex Worker Shelters Single Parent Social Media Social Security Socks Solutions Street Soccer Survival sex System Failure Systems Change Technology Tent Cities Tiny Homes Transgender Travelers Veteran Vietnam Veteran Violence Waiting list Welfare Working poor Youth EVENTS @home contests PBS road trip road trip 2009 road trip 2010 road trip 2011 road trip 2013 to fight youth homelessness sober birthday campaign SXSW TEDx INTERVIEWS Learn More Canadian Homelessness Coronavirus and Homelessness Criminalization of Homelessness Family Homelessness Homeless Seniors Homeless Veterans Homeless Youth Homelessness Mobile Homelessness Panhandling Tent Encampments U.K. Homelessness MISCELLANEOUS 360 video Awards Cause Marketing Dream Center Gates Foundation Google Glass Media Patreon Tribute World Trade Center YouTube More Updates

topic

By Location Alaska Albuquerque Allentown Amsterdam Anaheim Anchorage Ann Arbor Atlanta Austin Baton Rouge Bend Binghamton Boston Boulder Canada Cardiff Charlotte Chatsworth Chicago Chippenham Cleveland Columbia SC Columbus Dallas Denver Des Moines Detroit Edmonton Eugene Fayetteville Fort McMurray Fredericton Gainesville Glendale Great Falls Greensboro Harbor City Harrisburg Hawaii Hawthorne Hollywood Honolulu houston Ithaca Kalkaska Kelowna Koreatown Las Vegas Lima London London (Canada) Los Angeles Louisville Manchester Miami Minneapolis/St Paul Montreal Nashville New Orleans New York City Nickelsville Norway Oakland Ocala Oslo Ottawa Oxford Paradise Pasadena Peru Philadelphia Phoenix Pine Ridge Pittsburgh Portland Reseda Sacramento Salt Lake City San Diego San Francisco San Jose San Luis Obispo Santa Monica Saskatoon Seattle Shawnee Skid Row Springfield St John's St Louis St. Petersburg Syracuse Tacoma Tampa Toronto Traverse City Tulsa United Kingdom Vancouver Venice Beach Vermont Victoria Wales Washington DC Wentzville Westwood Wichita Wilmington Winnipeg Yellowknife By topic Addiction Advocacy Affordable housing Art and Music Awareness Charity Cold Weather College Students Community Involvement Coronavirus Couch Surfing Couple Criminalization Data Disabled Divorce Domestic violence Drug testing Education Employment Eviction Ex-convict Faith based Families Family conflict Female Financial crisis Foster care Harm reduction Health care HIV/AIDS Homeless count Homeless deaths Hostels (UK shelters) Hotels Housing First HUD Human trafficking Identification Incarceration Indigenous Invisible People Invisible Stories Job loss K2/Spice (Synthetic Marijuana) LGBT Libraries Lived Experience Male Mental illness Mobile Homeless Natural disasters NIMBY Outreach Panhandling Peer Support Pets Poverty Pregnant PTSD Public Feeding Racism Recycling Relationships Research Rural Schools Seniors Sex Offenders Sex Worker Shelters Single Parent Social Media Social Security Socks Solutions Street Soccer Survival sex System Failure Systems Change Technology Tent Cities Tiny Homes Transgender Travelers Veteran Vietnam Veteran Violence Waiting list Welfare Working poor Youth EVENTS @home contests PBS road trip road trip 2009 road trip 2010 road trip 2011 road trip 2013 to fight youth homelessness sober birthday campaign SXSW TEDx INTERVIEWS Learn More Canadian Homelessness Coronavirus and Homelessness Criminalization of Homelessness Family Homelessness Homeless Seniors Homeless Veterans Homeless Youth Homelessness Mobile Homelessness Panhandling Tent Encampments U.K. Homelessness MISCELLANEOUS 360 video Awards Cause Marketing Dream Center Gates Foundation Google Glass Media Patreon Tribute World Trade Center YouTube More Updates

Pallet’s Profits Soar Alongside Demand for Temporary Tiny ‘Homes’

Pallet shelter

Their Expensive Shoeboxes for Homeless People Are Popping Up All Over, With No Accompanying Boom in Permanent Housing Options in Sight

Pallet, the Washington-based, for-profit manufacturer of the glorified tool sheds we’ve written about before, has seen a 7,000% growth in demand for its amenity-light temporary housing product. Cities up and down the West Coast and throughout the country are turning to them for solutions that offer more safety and stability than a tent on the sidewalk.

The problem is that these cramped huts offer only a small step up from that in terms of quality of life. That minimal improvement comes with an eyewatering price tag. Cities end up blowing their budgets on next to nothing when they could invest just a little more to have safe, affordable, permanent housing options.

How Much Could a 64-Square-Foot Shack Cost?

That’s the $48 million question. Pallet advertises their 8×8, two-bed shed as costing just under $7,000. But the city of Los Angeles has spent $48,452,115 on constructing 11 different “tiny home villages” with 1,252 beds total. That’s 626 units at most. So the cost per hut comes to a staggering $77,399.54.

But that’s not all! There is also a $25,133,900 annual cost to operate these sites. Now we’re talking about a $3,345 ongoing monthly cost for a one-room shelter made out of plastic. 

The average rental price for a Los Angeles apartment more than ten times the size is only $2,661. And most of those come with such luxuries as a private bathroom, kitchen, and maybe even a washing machine to boot. The city of LA is not getting its money’s worth out of these Pallet villages.

What Does That Money Buy?

Not very much. Pallet’s tiny shelters include 2 to 4 twin-sized beds, a few shelves, a locking door, and locking windows. Optional features include electric hookups to power the two outlets, extra insulation for cold climates, interior lighting, and a heater and air conditioner. Light, heat, and electricity are optional features.

Safety features include:

  • A fire extinguisher.
  • Smoke detector.
  • Carbon monoxide detector.
  • Emergency second egress hatch in at least some units

The units are also independently inspected by local Fire Marshalls wherever they end up being installed, and Pallet is quick to point this out because more than one of their villages has caught fire in the past.

Bathroom, kitchen, laundry and common area facilities must be bought separately. A fully assembled, non-ADA compliant bathroom unit from Pallet with two toilets, sinks, and showers will cost you about $35,000. You can also get a big, empty 400 or 800-square-foot unit for just under $37,000 to fill with whatever you want.

How Much Does All of This Help?

Undeniably, access to Pallet shelters and other options like them can positively affect the lives of individuals. But very few people get to see that benefit. Ultimately, temporary housing initiatives like this are a short-term band-aid when we really need a long-term fix.

While conditions in these tiny plastic sheds may be an improvement for some unhoused people, they are still not suitable enough for comfortable habitation. This is justified as being a short-term, low-cost solution for people transitioning to permanent housing. But we’ve seen how “low-cost” it is, and it hasn’t proven to be very short-term either. Temporary shelter is designed to support a person over a short window of time as they transition into permanent affordable housing. The problem comes when there is no permanent affordable housing for them to transition into.

That’s the reality for most people using temporary housing options these days. Rather than passing through a temporary program and out of homelessness, the system is backed up. There’s nowhere for these people to move to. They either stay in “temporary housing” indefinitely or eventually find themselves back out on the streets.

Isn’t It Better Than Nothing, Though?

Technically, building these expensive and minimal temporary housing options is better than nothing. If doing nothing is the alternative. But at the same time, that money could have gone towards other projects that would make a much bigger bang for your buck. Take a look at the numbers again.

For just the annual operating costs, the city could have rented out 787 average apartments for a year and still saved $48 million. Instead, they got 626 plastic shacks with barely enough room for two people to put their shoes on at the same time.

Don’t get me wrong- having a private space off the street with easy access to facilities and services is a great thing for people currently living without access to any of those things. But we can do better than this.

However, it may not actually be better than nothing in this specific case.

Many local activists think that LA is in a rush to build all of these temporary tiny villages so that it’ll once again be allowed to legally enforce its laws against homelessness.

A federal court ruling has prevented the City of Los Angeles from ticketing or arresting unhoused people just for camping in public unless there is shelter available to them. The mad dash to build shelter, any shelter is all in an effort to reach a point where they can accommodate 60% of the city’s homeless population, at which point they believe they’ll be allowed to start criminalizing homelessness again.

Seen with this additional context, it’s easy to understand why these housing options aren’t beneficial. They’re not meant to be helpful to the unhoused people they ostensibly serve. They’re meant to be helpful to the local businesses and NIMBY residents who depend on police action to remove poor people from their sight. And the amount of money they’re willing to spend on that proves what we already knew- that their objections were never really about finances in the first place.


Kayla Robbins

Kayla Robbins

  

Kayla Robbins is a freelance writer who works with big-hearted brands and businesses. When she's not working, she enjoys knitting socks, rolling d20s, and binging episodes of The Great British Bake Off.

Related Topics



Your support can create amazing change

Join the campaign to end homelessness by supporting the only newsroom focused solely on the topic of homelessness. Our original reporting — posted five to seven days a week — can also be found on Apple News and Google News. Through storytelling, education, news, and advocacy, we are changing the narrative on homelessness.

Invisible People is a nonprofit organization. We rely on the support of friends like you — people who understand that well-written, carefully researched stories can change minds about this issue. And that’s what leads to true transformation and policy change. Our writers have their fingers on the pulse of homeless communities. Many are formerly or currently homeless themselves. They are the real experts, passionate about ending homelessness. Your support helps us tell the true story of this crisis and solutions that will end it. Your donations help make history by telling the real story of homelessness to inspire tangible actions to end it.

Your donation, big or small, will help bring real change.

DONATE NOW



Get the Invisible People newsletter


RECENT STORIES

homeless man in austin

Martin

Los Angeles Homeless Woman Lost Her Legs to Frostbite

Monica

homeless man in austin

David

Disabled Homeless Mom

Cori and her daughter


RECENT ARTICLES

yukon housing

What’s Fueling the Yukon’s Housing Crisis?

Craig Newmark Philanthropies

Craig Newmark Philanthropies Awards Invisible People $50,000 Grant

shelters are not for everyone

Shelters Aren’t Right For Everyone

family homelessness

Family Homelessness: A Gateway to Generational Trauma

Get the Invisible People newsletter