Opposition Grows Against Proposed Solutions for Homelessness


In the spring of 2017, citizens in Los Angeles voted to raise their own sales tax in an effort to reduce the epidemic levels of homelessness in California’s largest metropolitan area.

Other cities struggling with similar problems such as Portland and Seattle have created task forces and announced states of emergency to confront the intersectional problems at the core of the social issues associated with homelessness.

All across the United States, local governments, social service organizations and the general public are fighting to have the last word on how to address the social problems caused by homelessness. Many are willing to accept that homelessness is a problem. However, there is little consensus about how to best address it.

Despite the renewed impetus to address homelessness across the United States, there is an emerging backlash of opposition. This opposition is fighting to ensure that systemic poverty and inequality, central drivers of homelessness, remain entrenched in America’s urban centers.

While few would admit to wanting to perpetuate homelessness, it is clear that many U.S. citizens view homelessness in an unfavorable way. This is in part driven by media coverage on the topic.

The Role the Media Plays

Last year, San Francisco received the dubious title of “street poop capital of the United States” in response to an article published by RealtyHop. The article was widely shared and helped to perpetuate the growing trend of negative opposition against homeless activism and advocacy.

According to research carried out by the Washington Post, most American citizens have a favorable view about assisting the homeless with direct aid and subsidized housing.

Paradoxically however, the same study found that most of the public would prefer to make panhandling and sleeping in public parks illegal and punishable by incarceration.

Why Would This Be the Case?

The same research carried out by the Washington Post went a step further. It tried to uncover why the public has such a negative view about assisting the homeless. They found that based on media coverage such as the aforementioned RealtyHop piece, many in the general public associate the homelessness with things that are unclean.

As a result, instead of responding with compassionate regard and desire to assist, many  respond to the homeless issues in their communities with a sense of revulsion and a desire to turn away and avoid.

The authors from the Washington Post study write:

“As we expected, people who are more easily disgusted are more likely to support bans on public sleeping and panhandling than those who are less easily disgusted. But they are just as likely to support policies providing aid or housing to homeless people. We also found no evidence that disgust sensitivity predicts more negative attitudes toward homeless people in general.

We also showed that news coverage of homelessness can activate disgust sensitivity by referring to disease and uncleanliness. In an experiment embedded in our survey, respondents were randomly assigned to one of two groups. Each group read a short paragraph about homeless people. In the first (control) group, respondents read a paragraph with generic references to homelessness. In the second (treatment) group, respondents read a story that mentioned concerns about public urination, littering, and keeping communities clean and sanitary.

In the control group, which omitted direct references to disease or sanitation, we found the pattern described above. People who were more sensitive to disgust were about 11 percentage points more likely to support banning panhandling than those less sensitive to disgust, and about 17 percentage points more likely to support banning sleeping in public.”

Big City Problems, Big Money Opposition

Many Americans are interested in doing something to address homelessness. That is, as long as it does not mean placing a food bank or shelter in their neighborhood

In New York City, this is not a fairy tale but a real scenario which pitted city planners against billionaires desperate to ensure homeless resources were not able to move into their beloved corners of Manhattan.

Mayor Bill De Blasio had planned for a homeless shelter to be placed in the former Park Savoy Hotel at 158 W 58th St in midtown Manhattan. The property for the planned shelter is located right next to the most expensive skyscraper in the entire city, One57.  Predictably, the wealthy citizens of “billionaires row” did not take kindly to the idea of bringing a homeless shelter into their neighborhood. As of today, the fight continues.

The issue at the core of the debate of the New York City scenario is one that has been repeated across the nation: many view homeless citizens as carriers of disease, supporters of vice and harbingers of losses in property value. They are not seen as neighbors and colleagues but instead as something to be fearful of, something to guard against.

These pervasive viewpoints and the opposition against homeless resources are obviously a major barrier to addressing  homelessness in many communities.

Changing the Narrative

Believe it or not, the battle to end homelessness will be won not with funding but with widespread public support. Changing the narratives around homelessness is what Invisible People is all about.

We believe that by showing the world the real experience of what homelessness is and how it is caused, we will create the conditions necessary to drive the public to want to take up this cause.

Homeless individuals are normal everyday people just like you and me. They are people you know and people you have valued.

They are citizens with stories.

They are fathers, mothers, sons, daughters.

They are families.

They are friends.

They are people with resilience and dignity.

Homeless people are all too often invisible people but now is the time to change that!

John Heinz

John Heinz


John Heinz is a masters level social worker, educator and writer who helps businesses to remember the communities they serve.

Related Topics

Your support can create amazing change

Join the campaign to end homelessness by supporting the only newsroom focused solely on the topic of homelessness. Our original reporting — posted five to seven days a week — can also be found on Apple News and Google News. Through storytelling, education, news, and advocacy, we are changing the narrative on homelessness.

Invisible People is a nonprofit organization. We rely on the support of friends like you — people who understand that well-written, carefully researched stories can change minds about this issue. And that’s what leads to true transformation and policy change. Our writers have their fingers on the pulse of homeless communities. Many are formerly or currently homeless themselves. They are the real experts, passionate about ending homelessness. Your support helps us tell the true story of this crisis and solutions that will end it. Your donations help make history by telling the real story of homelessness to inspire tangible actions to end it.

Your donation, big or small, will help bring real change.


Get the Invisible People newsletter



Homeless with Wife in Philadelphia


17 Years in the Military to 10 Years Homeless in Los Angeles


Van Life NOT by Choice: Elderly Homeless Woman Needs Housing



Indigenous People fighting Homelessness

Indigenous People Deemed 26 Times More Likely to Experience Homelessness in Minnesota

emergency shelter arrest

Confessions of an Emergency Family Shelter Worker, Part 1

homeless war veteran

Being a War Veteran Makes You Statistically More Likely to Become Homeless


Woman Experiencing Chronic Homelessness Talks About Suicide

Get the Invisible People newsletter