San Francisco Chooses Handcuffs over Housing Homeless People

homelessness in san francisco is growing

Advocates say San Francisco has chosen to increase enforcement of ordinances punishing homelessness over providing housing for its growing homeless population.

Mayor London Breed has pledged to make the city “tent-free” through a combination of services and increased shelter options. However, her administration has gone as far as to remove the portable restrooms that people experiencing homelessness use. San Francisco Chronicle.

City officials put out over three dozen restrooms for people experiencing homelessness at the beginning of the pandemic. Some officials are concerned that the services are “attracting more people experiencing homelessness” to the Bay Area.

“While I do not believe that the porta-potties cause homelessness, I think that San Francisco attracts unsheltered people to our City due to a lack of real enforcement and the many amenities we provide to folks,” said Jeff Kositsky, the manager of the city’s Healthy Streets Operation Center (HSOC).

At the same time, extreme poverty is becoming as prevalent as the city’s challenging hills and eclectic architecture.

According to the latest Point in Time (PIT) Count, 64 percent of the over 8,000 people experiencing homelessness in the city live unsheltered.

Kelley Cutler, an organizer with the Coalition on Homelessness, a San Francisco-based outreach organization, says the tactic is part of a broader push by some city officials to get rid of “visible homelessness.”

Recently revealed emails between Kositsky and Alaric Degrafinried, the Director of San Francisco’s Department of Public Works, show the two discussing which “encampments” would be the best to clear ahead of a February tent count by San Franciso’s Heathy Streets Operation Center.

“We still don’t have public access to shelters and can’t get on a waitlist. Yet HSOC has been doing sweeps so the Mayor can brag about pre-COVID tent count numbers,” Cutler said in a tweet.

Homelessness in the Bay Area is not new.

For the better part of three decades, mayors from Dianne Feinstein to Breed have tried to solve the city’s persistent homelessness. KQED, San Francisco spends around $300 million on homeless prevention services annually. Yet, the day-to-day population has increased.

Journalist Steve Talbot said “homeless people” was not a common phrase used in the city during the 1970s and 1980s. It would be at least another decade before it became an issue, he added.

During the Feinstein years, homelessness was treated as a “passing phenomenon,” according to KQED’s report. Her strategy was Reagan-esque, relying heavily on private and faith-based shelters to pick up where the government had left off. Ultimately, many shelters fell into disrepair. In one infamous event, her administration converted municipal busses into homeless shelters.

After Mayor Art Agnos’ failures with his “beyond shelter” initiatives, Mayor Frank Jordan implemented an enforcement-based approach to homelessness in 1996, similar to today’s attempts. Police routinely cleared the streets to usher people experiencing homelessness into services and shelter. Local police issued over 6,000 citations for quality-of-life infractions during Jordan’s tenure.

Since Jordan, Mayor Willie Brown was the most successful at building affordable housing for low-income earners. However, he was also known for enforcing anti-homeless ordinances and leveled a homeless shelter to build a parking lot.

Before Breed took office, Mayor Ed Lee created the San Francisco Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) in 2016. The agency is tasked with spending at least $1 billion through 2020 on homelessness reduction and prevention programs. Last year, the agency reported significant decreases in families and unaccompanied youths experiencing homelessness. However, the agency also noted an increase in individuals experiencing homelessness.

Mayor Breed has led several successful initiatives to both address homelessness and create affordable housing.

Her administration has opened a safe parking site for people to sleep in their legally-owned vehicles. She has even proposed creating a street outreach team to replace local police officers called to address homeless issues. Breed’s administration has also secured an additional 887 housing vouchers under the federal American Rescue Plan. She has plans to increase housing placements by 6,000 by 2022.

Still, the number of people experiencing homelessness has increased by over 800 percent over the past two decades. In 2000, the PIT volunteers counted just 1,800 people sleeping rough. Advocates say San Francisco’s 2019 count is closer to 9,700 rather than the city-reported total of 8,800.

Regardless, Cutler said the people she works with on the street are “desperate for resources.”

Diane Yentel, President of the National Low Income Housing Coalition, says situations like these will become more desperate as the federal eviction moratorium nears its June 30 expiration date.

“If the Biden Administration allows the moratorium to expire before emergency rental assistance money reaches renters, there’ll be a historic wave of evictions in the summer and fall,” Yentel tweeted.

Contact your legislators and tell them you support both extending the eviction moratorium and housing not handcuffs.

Robert Davis

Robert Davis

Robert is a freelance journalist based in Colorado who covers housing, police, and local government.

Related Topics

Get the Invisible People newsletter


Homeless man sitting on sidewalk near Skid Row Los Angeles


homeless woman in Grants Pass


Police Force Homeless Man To Relocate Twice In 24 Hours


80-year-old Woman Homeless in Sad Diego

Miss Katie


cycle of homelessness

Examining the Intersection of Homelessness and Social Issues

street homelessness in California - homeless people more likely to end up back on the streets rather than permanent housing after interim housing programs

Audits Expose Failure of California’s Interim Housing Programs

Seattle Serial Killer targeting homeless people

Seattle Serial Killer Brutally Targets Homeless Victims

Increased homeownership could be on the horizon with proposed plan from President Biden

Biden Proposes Homeownership Plan as Affordability Hits All-Time Low

Get the Invisible People newsletter